
My Dead Girlfriend Vol. 1 Cover.
The art looks like it’d be more at home on Nickelodeon …
I recently picked up the first volume of My Dead Girlfriend by Eric Wight. The concept sounded interesting. It’s kinda like the creepy/funny stuff Tim Burton does so well. Who could resist Tim Burton in manga form? Not me. I love that kind of stuff so I had to get it.
From the back cover.
Finney Bleak lives in a world of horror - literally. His family members are ghosts, his classmates are monsters, and Finney is the most normal kid in school. But within the halls of Mephisto Prep, normal is the new weird and Finney dangles from the lowest rung of the social evolutionary ladder.
Eh, sounds ok, but nothing spectacular. I kinda wonder if the person who wrote that read the book or not. It’s correct as far as it goes, but doesn’t really tell you anything about the personality of the manga. That’s one of it’s strong points. It has a lot of personality. We’ve seen schools filled with monsters, witches and aliens before. It’s kinda hard to bring something new to it. I have to say, I enjoyed the description of the different cliques. Here’s my favorite.
The Aberzombies — Undead kids who take non-conformity to such an extreme that they must conform to each other or be harshly ridiculed.
There are a lot of monsters in the cast. Being normal is what sets Finney apart from almost everyone else. It makes him the weird kid. He’d probably fit in better if he died. At least then he’d be just another ghost. Now we come to the big problem with the story. Death is no big deal. If someone dies, they just turn into a ghost.
Finney has a dream where he’s running from the Grim Reaper. I kept wondering why he was running. Almost everyone in his family is a ghost. He’d fit in better at school. So what’s to be afraid of? It really takes a lot of the impact out of the story. If death can’t be scary, what can? That’s not good. It cripples the potential of the story.
The art looks like it’d be more at home on Nickelodeon or Cartoon Network than in a manga, but I won’t hold that against it. It’s drawn well, and with the wide variety of styles in manga these days it’s being very nit picky to say something doesn’t belong. Don’t be surprised if you see commercials for this series on one of those channels. It’s just begging to be animated for one of ‘em. It would have to be toned down some, and probably re-titled. Other than that it’d fit perfectly following Ben Ten or Danny Phantom.
If you liked The Corpse Bride, give it a shot. Otherwise, wait for the cartoon it should have been to start with.
My Dead Girlfriend, creepy, funny, Tim Burton, manga, Finney Bleak, horror, ghosts, monsters, weird, school, witches, aliens, Aberzombies, Undead, Nickelodeon, Cartoon Network, Ben Ten, Danny Phantom, The Corpse Bride